Re: FT8 contest mode incompatibly


Bill
 

Scott,

Nice work on 300+!

When working the DXpedition(s) I became obsessed about  stations sharing signal reports but not grids. That until Mike FKO reminded me that I had made legal contacts because I was not in a contest and therefore any exchange will pass for a legal contact...... even funny little numbers. I'll be glad when this newby confusion ends......

Bill W7QQ


On Mon, Jul 22, 2019 at 1:29 PM Scott K5TA <k5ta@...> wrote:
To add a little extra confusion to the stew,  I have noticed that some people, mostly on (grid) DXpeditions have been calling CQ TEST outside of contests, especially on MSK144, probably looking for the shortest possible QSOs. 

My total is shown below. Very casual FT8 only. The big advantage of that mode for me is that I can sit in the bedroom watching TV with an iPad in my lap and work people via a remote desktop app. 

I did work TI2 for a new DXCC, and enough grids to put me over 300 if everyone uploads to LoTW.  I’m happy. 

-Scott K5TA 

image1.jpeg


On Jul 22, 2019, at 11:39 AM, James Duffey <JamesDuffey@...> wrote:

Don’t worry about the NIL. I suspect that most of the guys doing that are casual contestants and won’t submit a log. 

James Duffey KK6MC
Cedar Crest NM

On Jul 22, 2019, at 10:00, KC7QY <kc7qy@...> wrote:

Keith,

I also saw a lot of non-TEST CQs. Generally I passed them by and worked the ones calling CQ Test (probably hurt my humble score but that's another story). The ones I did call or who called me when I was CQing generally came back with a 73 after my RR 73. Guess I'll have to wait for the log checking report to see how many NIL I get back.

Jim KC7QY


On Monday, July 22, 2019, 09:36:00 AM MDT, Keith Morehouse <w9rm@...> wrote:


Anyone seriously operating this weekends contest and using FT8 probably had this happen.

You're cruising .313 looking for those new mults or whatever, you see someone CQing WITHOUT the word TEST in the CQ message and you instinctively know they're not in contest mode.  No worries, you think.  The WSJTX boffins have tuned the program to compensate for the difference in exchange and you know autosequence will seamlessly pull you through.  You call and, sure enough, back comes the 'funny little number' exchange.  You reply with a NA contest mode exchange (because you're contesting, right ?) and.... back comes a repeat - no autosequence.  What ??  OK, maybe I got QRMed.  Try again, and same thing.  You can't progress to the finish.

What you do now is left to the individual.  What I did was terminate the Q and moved on.  You might have fiddled with the setup to switch out of contest mode.  Whatever... the Q was either made or not.

What this did, other then temporarily piss me off and cause name calling that nobody heard but me and the shack spiders, was confused me.  HOW could this happen....the boffins....they fixed this.  Was the other guy manually interfering with autosequence ?  Was the other guy that insistent on his funny number ?  I started ignoring those obviously not in contest mode.

This morning, after reading a soapbox comment on 3830, it finally hit me.... (I'm pretty focused on operating during the 'test).  It's.....The Clones !!  Those knock-offs of WSJT - JTDX, MHSV !  THEY don't have contest mode !   They can't autosequence past TX2.  So, what to do about this incompatibly ?  It's pretty obvious the clones aren't going to add CM if they haven't already and there are those contest haters that wouldn't use it anyway, but still insist on trying to WORK contesters.

I'm thinking maybe the solution is to add some kind of 'quick button' behavior to WSJTX that drops the program out of contest mode for just one Q and resets back into CM after the 73 (or something).  Does anyone have another idea ?  If a number of high level contesters presented such a request maybe the WSJT powers would respond.  Or, maybe you think it's a non-issue....or maybe a quick work around all ready exists that doesn't require a guy to drop in and change his setup and I'm just clueless ?

-W9RM



Keith Morehouse
via MotoG

Join main@nmvhf.groups.io to automatically receive all group messages.